Gary Marcus invokes steel-mill decline to argue neoclouds hinge on LLM profitability
GaryMarcus · x · 2026-09-21
Gary Marcus argues two points in a debate with investor Gavin Baker: the more profitable the LLM-providing business is as a whole, the better neoclouds will do — and if LLM returns on capital stay weak, the neocloud business will suffer.
He likens high-cost compute providers to America's collapsed steel industry, citing Baltimore's Sparrows Point mill (once the world's largest, 30,000+ workers at peak, closed for good in 2012).
Baker counters that the auto-driven rise of steel and oil consumption is the better analogy, since not all token-production inputs are commodities — and CoreWeave, Oracle and Nvidia valuations should logically be negatively correlated with model-layer margins.
Related event: Investor and Gary Marcus Clash Over LLM Economics and Neoclouds(2 posts)→
More from Venture
- Anyone's agents actually making money? A dev's reality check on x402 agent payments — thranduilsson · 2026-09-21
- Compute lending panic overblown: $10B+ in data center deals priced in two months — Jsevillamol · 2026-09-21
- $4.2M ARR AI acquisition target turned out to be one GPT-4o call and 600 lines of glue code — alex_verem · 2026-09-21
- Tesla Robotaxis now cost slightly more than Uber in Austin, but scale could flip pricing — JOBhakdi · 2026-09-21
- Commentary: AI buildout may be disinflationary, but the Fed uses it as cover for Main Street neglect — McDonaghMatthew · 2026-09-21
- 'Nobody paid me a single dollar' became a book title within a week — and someone bought it — itsOmSarraf_ · 2026-09-21