AI music videos should be judged by how easy they are to fix, not first-draft quality
Positive-Page1631 · reddit · 2026-09-15
The author argues AI video comparisons focus too much on first-draft quality (image, motion, prompt accuracy) while music videos fail after the draft: faces drift mid-video, choruses hit flat visuals, and scenes that look fine alone feel wrong in context.
He contrasts tools: Kling and Runway are strong for individual shots, Neural Frames leans audio-reactive, and SondoAI takes a full-song approach where you start from a complete MV and replace scenes that don't work.
The useful comparison dimensions: attempts needed to fix one bad scene, whether replacements fit surrounding shots, and how much cleanup remains.
More from Multimodal
- Google DeepMind on speech-to-speech: conversational, intelligent, multimodal — pick two — AI Engineer · 2026-09-15
- ChatGPT Image Editing Keeps Failing the Simplest Meme Instruction — Imchaman · 2026-09-15
- AI video series lets you dive into Klimt's The Kiss — IamIfOnly · 2026-09-15
- Magehold: A Small AI-Generated Magic Scene with Striking VFX — MosskeepForest · 2026-09-15
- Local Video Gen Start to Finish: What Does Your LTX + ComfyUI Pipeline Look Like? — Normal_Frosting8519 · 2026-09-15
- ACE Step 1.5 Music Generation Now Runs Locally on Android via CPU or OpenCL GPU — sgcego · 2026-09-15