Reason Review Slams Yudkowsky's AI Doom Book: Extraordinary Claims, No Evidence
neil_chilson · x · 2026-09-10
Neil Chilson reviews Yudkowsky and Soares's new book If Anyone Builds It, Everyone Dies in Reason magazine.
Key points:
- The claim that superintelligence will inevitably kill everyone requires extraordinary evidence, but the book offers only a daisy chain of thought experiments, unexamined premises, and a linguistic sleight of hand.
- The argument rests on the alignment problem: AI is "grown" via training, so its goals can't be fully specified; any slight divergence from human values leads to relentless optimization and human elimination.
- Chilson argues the authors' blindness to real-world complexity yields only despair, ignoring how intelligence-augmenting tools could deliver widespread, unprecedented prosperity.
- Their proposal effectively amounts to outlawing promising AI progress.
Related event: Ex-FTC Tech Chief Neil Chilson Takes Aim at Yudkowsky's AI Doom Argument(8 posts)→
More from AGI Musings
- Caught between two extremes: 'we're all dying' doomers vs 'AI risk is a psyop' deniers — gabriel1 · 2026-09-11
- Gary Marcus dissects the 'AI kills everyone by 2030' claim: no extinction, but real damage to address — GaryMarcus · 2026-09-11
- Gary Marcus mocks AGI arguments that rely on 'AI will think of things we can't imagine' — GaryMarcus · 2026-09-11
- 30-year technologist slams AI doom activists: record safety is historic — robleclerc · 2026-09-11
- Markets underprice AGI and overprice stagnation, argues Ronald Qiao — abhiadesai · 2026-09-11
- MILA's Irina Rish: AGI is practically here, ahead of my 7-year CERC schedule — irinarish · 2026-09-11