New hypothesis paper argues consciousness and cognition are separate evolutionary lineages, with six falsifiable predictions
rjhaier · x · 2026-09-03
Jeff Stibel published a hypothesis paper in Frontiers in Neuroscience arguing:
- Cognition and consciousness are separate evolutionary lineages; consciousness arises when an organism must coordinate conflicting regulatory processes affecting its own viability
- Functional precursors predate nervous systems, first appearing in boundary-preserving chemical and metabolic regulation, forming a ladder of proto-control, meta-control, and settlement control
- Implication: artificial consciousness won't emerge from cognitive sophistication alone — it requires self-maintaining systems that settle competing demands under real constraint
- The framework yields six falsifiable predictions across comparative biology, neuroscience, and AI
More from AGI Musings
- Cambridge professor David Krueger slams Dean's apology: 'You don't get to just say my bad for deceiving you' — DavidSKrueger · 2026-09-03
- Anders Sandberg to speak on human autonomy in the AI age at EAGx Oxford, Sept 25-27 — anderssandberg · 2026-09-03
- Using OpenEvidence, a user found a cancer clinical trial that saved his father — saranormous · 2026-09-03
- Gary Marcus mocks Sam Altman's AI bubble warning: bubble architect calls it a bubble — GaryMarcus · 2026-09-03
- CoT monitorability not abandoned yet, but new techniques risk a race to the bottom — DavidSKrueger · 2026-09-03
- Sam Altman warns at G20: cybersecurity things 'will go very wrong' without urgent action — RebeccaBellan · 2026-09-03