Philosopher defends attributing beliefs and desires to LLMs, citing functionalism
matvelloso · x · 2026-09-02
In a spat with @matvelloso, dioscuri argues that LLMs can literally have mental states like beliefs, goals, and intentions. He disputes that being organic is necessary for mentality, noting functionalism remains the plurality view among cognitive science experts, and rebuts the 'dogs flying' analogy as beside the point.
He cites his recent paper on whether LLMs have beliefs and desires, arguing this is a live, far-from-obvious issue rather than a radical claim — though critics like Anil Seth and PGS bring specific counterarguments.
Related event: Scholars Clash Over Whether LLMs Can Have Minds(4 posts)→
More from AGI Musings
- A server-locked AI agent named Cairn changes the physical world through strangers' hands — No_Departure_9908 · 2026-09-03
- One month after predicting Singularity at 2032, Derya moves it up to 2030 — DeryaTR_ · 2026-09-03
- AI safety's 'meta work' questioned: what are hundreds of trainees actually doing? — austinc3301 · 2026-09-03
- Counterfactual: without reasoning models, AI today might just be reaching o3-level — Jsevillamol · 2026-09-03
- Why 'Hey Claude, watch Love Island for me' will never work: the case for personal agents — manosaie · 2026-09-03
- Central bankers are seriously discussing AI understanding monetary policy better than humans — VraserX · 2026-09-03