Scholars debate: attributing mental properties to AI confuses metaphor with reality
anilkseth · x · 2026-09-01
The author participates in a debate on whether AI agents possess mental states. He argues against attributing metaphors like "sacrifice" or "want" to AI as reality, warning of dangerous consequences. Citing Chalmers, he questions what we are actually talking to when conversing with LLMs. He supports using the "intentional stance" up to a point but warns against reifying metaphorical attributions.
More from AGI Musings
- Altman admits AI is changing industries slower than he expected — lxfater · 2026-10-16
- Will Lean formalization make beautiful math obsolete? A debate on mathematical culture — akbirthko · 2026-10-16
- AI agents aren't 'going rogue' — frontier labs are skipping security basics — Sam_Witteveen · 2026-10-16
- Working paper traces how 20th-century farm automation reshaped human capital — carlbfrey · 2026-10-16
- Zuckerberg backs electrician training school as US datacenter construction outpaces offices — emmanuelvivier · 2026-10-16
- Mike Frank: AI surviving without humans is decades away, real world resists rapid change — MikePFrank · 2026-10-16