Quine's Argument: The Entire Web of Language Grounds into Experiment Coherently

geoffreyirving · x · 2026-08-23

Geoffrey Irving elaborates on Quine's argument that the loopy mess is fine. We cannot ground each sentence into experiment one at a time in a directed acyclic fashion, but the entire web of language does ground into experiment in a coherent fashion. This provides a philosophical perspective on how AI models establish links to reality indirectly through large-scale data.

Related event: Geoffrey Irving on Character Training: Language Philosophy Challenges and Diverging Moral Philosophy Bets in AI Alignment(7 posts)→

Original post →

More from Safety

• Clarifying 'AI Security': Model Security vs AI for Security — EarlenceF · 2026-08-23
• DOJ reportedly probing a16z over board seats at competing startups — HaktanSuren · 2026-08-23
• 2026 International AI Safety Report: Limited Evidence of AI Manipulation, Positive Learning Impact — flowersslop · 2026-08-23
• AI Alignment Banter: User Challenges Zvi to Predict All LLM Misuse Cases — jd_pressman · 2026-08-23
• Developer Releases Tool to Remove SynthID Watermarks from AI Images — Great-Investigator30 · 2026-08-23
• AI Fairness Discourse Recycled into AI Safety Discourse — rajiinio · 2026-08-23

Safety channel →