Can AI Replace Doctors? Grady Booch Argues Medicine is More Than Diagnosis
Grady_Booch · x · 2026-08-20
Grady Booch critiques a viral JAMA Perspective claiming autonomous AI will soon exceed AI-aided physicians. Booch shares a story of an 80-year-old patient with a speech-impairing brain tumor who refuses chemo to care for his sick wife, asking 'which model solves that?' He argues that the paper reduces medicine to diagnosis and decision-making—perhaps 10% of a doctor's day. Booch emphasizes that the core of medicine involves human empathy and complex contextual care, elements that current algorithms cannot quantify or replace.
Related event: JAMA Article Claiming AI Beats Doctors Sparks Medical Backlash(2 posts)→
More from AGI Musings
- "An LLM doesn't understand anything" gets the perfect parody reversal: neither do you — VoidStateKate · 2026-10-16
- Nina Schick: Europe's Policy Circle Still Doesn't Believe FSD, Orbital Compute Are Real — NinaDSchick · 2026-10-16
- Meta's Superintelligence Lab Runs 200+ Direct Reports—A Lesson for Flat Multi-Agent Systems — peterjliu · 2026-10-16
- Andy Masley lays out his version of effective altruism, pluralism over utilitarian math — RobbWiller · 2026-10-16
- We're forgetting how much of a miracle GPT-3.5-level intelligence was, and it may cost us — EigenGender · 2026-10-16
- Ex-Anthropic's McDonagh Builds Compute Intelligence Agency to Study Frontier AI Costs — McDonaghMatthew · 2026-10-16