DeepMind Paper: LLMs Can Derive Relativity But Cannot 'Invent' It
rohanpaul_ai · x · 2026-08-13
A position paper from Google DeepMind explores the limitations of LLMs in scientific discovery, arguing that while LLMs can deduce known theories, they struggle with the 'abductive jump' from experience to a new explanatory premise.
Key arguments:
- Three Stages of Discovery: Separates discovery into induction (extracting rules), deduction (deriving consequences), and abduction (jumping to new premises). LLMs handle the first two but lack abduction.
- The Einstein Case Study: Newtonian gravity fit observations extremely well (errors at 10⁻⁹). A compression-driven system would have little gradient toward rebuilding spacetime, unlike Einstein, who was motivated by conceptual conflicts.
- Proposed Direction: The paper suggests developing action-controllable world models where agents can intervene in physically consistent simulations to translate simulated experience into candidate axioms.
More from AGI Musings
- Anthropic Research: Identical AI Agents Amplify Systemic Failures — rohanpaul_ai · 2026-08-13
- Dev's Take: AI Hasn't Ended Labor or Saved the Environment — threepointone · 2026-08-13
- DeepMind CEO: AI Cannot Generate Original Discoveries Yet, So We Are Not at AGI — TansuYegen · 2026-08-13
- Don't Bet Against the Largest AI Capex Cycle: Demand and Revenue Surging — firstadopter · 2026-08-13
- AI Safety Expert Warns of Growing Cyber Harm Risks from AI Agents — S_OhEigeartaigh · 2026-08-13
- Anthropic's Internal Model Solves Hadamard Matrix of Order 668, Widening Research Gap — Luuigi · 2026-08-13