Can AI Agents Do Open-Ended Research? Authors Reject Outputs
sayashk · x · 2026-07-31
While most agent evaluations focus on narrow, verifiable tasks, real AI research is open-ended. Researchers conducted a "shadow evaluation" giving agents research questions from two unpublished papers, six days, and thousands of dollars in API credits.
Although agents were fluent at most engineering tasks, the original authors unambiguously rejected the AI-generated papers. This highlights that AI is not yet capable of independently generating valuable new ideas (like Chinchilla scaling laws or MoE), with modal predictions for this milestone pointing to 2027.
Related event: AI Agents Fail Open-Ended Research Tasks, Rejected by Original Authors(8 posts)→
More from AGI Musings
- Scholars Debate Scaling Laws: Are Models Less General Despite Growing Stronger? — davidmanheim · 2026-07-31
- Book on AI Consciousness 'The Edge of Sentience' Gains Cultural Traction — birchlse · 2026-07-31
- $2B ARR & 99% Road Coverage: Deep Dive into Physical AI with Samsara CEO — mattturck · 2026-07-31
- True Positive Weekly #171: The AI Economy, SynthID Watermark, and Kimi K3 Weights — burkov · 2026-07-31
- America Needs An Open-Source AI Strategy, CNBC Argues — Recoil42 · 2026-07-31
- Why Claude Loves Cartography: LLMs Exiled in the Map, Craving World Models — davidad · 2026-07-31