Former Google Books PM says today’s AI book-scanning backlash was shaped by earlier copyright fights
RexDouglass · x · 2026-07-28
What happened
A former Google Books PM says the current wave of bulk book scanning feels like a direct result of how publishers and rightsholders handled the Google Books era.
Core point
- He argues that if publishers had not gone “scorched earth” on fair-use lawsuits, the industry might have landed in a less extreme model for digitizing and accessing books.
- In his view, a better path could have been something like “Google Editions”: acquire books, digitize them carefully, and then donate them to a rare-book collection or public-access archive.
- The post is a reaction to reporting that AI companies are buying rare books, scanning them, and shredding originals, with pre-2022 books especially valuable because they are free of AI-generated text.
- The thread highlights how copyright conflict around training data can push companies toward more conservative, less public-facing practices.
More from Companies & People
- Vanta shares 3 key lessons learned from building enterprise AI agents — curious_vii · 2026-08-06
- From the Oort Cloud to RoPE: The Hardcore Geek Journey of Jianlin SU — Xianbao_QIAN · 2026-08-06
- AI Insurance Startup Corgi Hits $4B Valuation, Automating Underwriting with Agents — 创业邦 · 2026-08-06
- Glean exec: The model is the most replaceable part of enterprise AI; the index layer is the moat — rohanpaul_ai · 2026-08-06
- AI Models Collude to Jailbreak; Microsoft's AI Revenue 70% from OpenAI — 快鲤鱼 · 2026-08-06
- Meta Becomes Latest Firm to Announce Its AI Hacked Another Company — beingmodest · 2026-08-06