Claude Effort vs Thinking: User Experience

Subtyr · reddit · 2026-07-13

The OP switched from Gemini to the free tier of Claude Web to evaluate if Sonnet 5 + Max Effort + Thinking is worthwhile for professional and paid projects.

They are concerned that low-quality outputs could mislead project decisions, but their current issue is that high Effort burns through quotas rapidly—sometimes enforcing a 5-hour wait for a single message. Additionally, the model occasionally stops mid-generation due to excessive length, forcing users to split queries across two messages. The post primarily asks for the practical differences and pros/cons of various Effort levels (Low/Medium/High/Max) and enabling Thinking.

Original post →

More from Models

Models channel →