ICLR authors lament no-win review process dominated by AI-like reviewers
ICLR 2027 authors describe a no-win review cycle: adding requested experiments draws criticism for changing too much, while not doing so invites 'AI slop' rejections, leaving authors feeling they are persuading an agent rather than a human reviewer.
2026-11-17 ~ 2026-11-17 · 2 related posts
- ICLR authors say AI-reviewed peer review feels like 'pleasing an agent, not a person' — murat_kocaoglu_ · 2026-11-17
- ICLR 2027 rebuttal catch-22: new experiments deemed "too much change," rebuttals dismissed as "AI slop" — SimpleObvious4048 · 2026-11-17