Identical ICLR reviews spark suspicions of AI-written peer review

After ICLR reviews were released, users found three reviewers gave near-identical comments, one apparently leaving AI-generated text intact, renewing concerns about LLM-written peer review.

2026-11-06 ~ 2026-11-07 · 3 related posts

• ICLR reviews drop and two are word-for-word identical, third starts 'Certainly! Here is a review' — ziv_ravid · 2026-11-06
• ICLR Reviewers Accused of Copy-Paste LLM Reviews, One Starts With 'Certainly!' — LucaAmb · 2026-11-06
• ICLR reviews turn meme-worthy: identical reviewer comments and one likely written by ChatGPT — Dr_Alex_Crimi · 2026-11-07