Developer finds Opus repeats the same mistakes despite explicit prompts
Developer ivanbezdomny's hands-on experiments show that Claude Opus (including Opus 5.5) repeatedly makes the same structural mistakes on similar tasks, and that explicit warnings in prompts fail to correct them. He proposes replacing prohibition-style prompting with a generate-critique-rewrite iterative workflow.
Confirmed
- When drawing spoons and forks, Opus repeatedly made the same structural errors; even with explicit warnings in the initial prompt and direct statements like "your side view is wrong, compare with real utensil photos," the model failed to grasp the problem and even claimed nothing was wrong.
- When building a 3D game, Opus made physics-intuition errors in side-view modeling of spoons/forks; prompting corrections were equally ineffective. The author concludes the model operates on priors—it can "build a 3D game" without truly understanding the physical world.
- When asked to design a spoon-manufacturing workflow, Opus 5.5 made a string of obvious errors; after opening a new session and explicitly telling it to avoid those specific mistakes, the model reproduced nearly the identical flawed design, only with a flashier UI the user disliked.
- The author expects a third from-scratch attempt would likely repeat the same errors.
- In AI-assisted writing of news copy, he avoids forbidding mistakes and instead generates a draft, then has the model critique and rewrite it.
Why it matters
- These experiments suggest that "forbidding errors in prompts" is often ineffective for current models, and that relying on iterative correction beats fine-tuning models to avoid specific mistakes.
- The author's alternative—generate a draft, then self-critique and rewrite—uses workflow design to compensate for the model's lack of genuine physical understanding.
2026-10-04 ~ 2026-10-04 · 5 related posts
Primary sources
- Opus 5.5 rebuilt the same flawed spoon manufacturing process even after being told its mistakes — ivan_bezdomny ·
- Dev finds Opus can build 3D games but can't perceive a wrong fork side view — ivan_bezdomny ·
- Writer uses generate-critique-rewrite loop to fix AI errors instead of forbidding them — ivan_bezdomny ·
- [source] Opus 5.5 rebuilt the same flawed spoon manufacturing process even after being told its mistakes — ivan_bezdomny · 2026-10-04
- Opus 5.5 repeats the exact spoon-manufacturing mistake it was warned about — ivan_bezdomny · 2026-10-04
- Claude Opus keeps making the same spoon and fork errors even when told explicitly — ivan_bezdomny · 2026-10-04
- [source] Dev finds Opus can build 3D games but can't perceive a wrong fork side view — ivan_bezdomny · 2026-10-04
- [source] Writer uses generate-critique-rewrite loop to fix AI errors instead of forbidding them — ivan_bezdomny · 2026-10-04