Dartmouth professors use Google Docs version history to keep research papers in the AI era
Brendan Nyhan, a government professor at Dartmouth, published "How to Assign Research Papers Again" in The Chronicle of Higher Education, pushing back against the idea of abandoning research papers in the AI era and offering three methods to counter AI ghostwriting. Economist Paul Novosad extended the discussion into assessment design.
Confirmed
- One practice already used successfully at Dartmouth: requiring students to write in Google Docs and using version history as evidence of human writing, preserving the value of the paper assignment while verifying the process.
- Paul Novosad's strategic point: rather than relying on detection tools, instructors should design assessments on platforms like Canvas so that cheating requires extensive premeditation and effort—making it an unambiguous suspension-level offense if caught, thereby changing students' calculus.
- The discussion also referenced Jeff Friedman's writing on assessment design in the AI era.
Unconfirmed
- birchlse argued the mechanism has limits: AI can edit a Google Doc paragraph by paragraph and fabricate a plausible version history, making it a filter that stops novices but not experts. Novosad responded that anti-cheating measures need not be perfect—only costly. This dispute remains unresolved.
Why it matters
- The exchange offers an actionable approach to a universal higher-education dilemma: rather than perfect detection, use process design and deterrence to shift the cost-benefit structure of cheating.
2026-09-30 ~ 2026-10-01 · 5 related posts
Primary sources
- Dartmouth Prof: We Don't Have to Give Up on Papers — Three Ways to Counter AI Cheating — paulnovosad ·
- Dartmouth Profs Keep Assigning Papers by Using Google Docs Version History to Prove Human Writing — paulnovosad ·
- Prof's Anti-Cheating Playbook: Make AI Cheating Require Planning, Punish Hard — paulnovosad ·
- [source] Dartmouth Prof: We Don't Have to Give Up on Papers — Three Ways to Counter AI Cheating — paulnovosad · 2026-09-30
- [source] Dartmouth Profs Keep Assigning Papers by Using Google Docs Version History to Prove Human Writing — paulnovosad · 2026-10-01
- [source] Prof's Anti-Cheating Playbook: Make AI Cheating Require Planning, Punish Hard — paulnovosad · 2026-10-01
- Economist on AI-era exam design: make cheating require costly planning, right inside Canvas — paulnovosad · 2026-10-01
- Anti-cheating tools catch amateurs while skilled AI cheats prosper, researchers argue — birchlse · 2026-10-01